University Textbooks; Research and Writting

University Textbooks; Research and Writting

Review and Criticism of the book "Geometry of Qur'anic sciences and Hadith" Written by Mohammad Alizadeh Qaimieh

Document Type : Research Paper

Author
Zahra Akbari
Assistant Professor of Department of Quranic and Hadith Sciences, Faculty of Humanities, Kosar University, Bojnord, Iran.
10.30487/rwab.2025.2023723.1605
Abstract
Textbooks play an important role in achieving educational goals in higher education centers, and the higher the quality of the textbook, the higher the quality of education. One of the first sources that was written for the course "Geometry of Quranic and Hadith Knowledge" in the field of theology and Islamic studies with a focus on Quranic and Hadith sciences is the book "Geometry of Qur'anic sciences and Hadith"written by Mr. Mohammad Alizadeh Qamiyeh. Despite the valuable efforts of the author in writing and editing, this work is not far from content and structural problems and needs serious criticism. In this article, which is organized in a descriptive-analytical way, the book of Geometry of Qur'anic sciences and Hadith is reviewed and criticized in terms of form and appearance, content, structure and method. The findings of the research show that this book is very weak in terms of form and appearance, and the content indicates the author's lack of mastery over the text and ultimately lack of innovation. Also, the structure of the book can be considered incoherent and in terms of methodology, the lack of reference in many quotations and the use of weak sources can be mentioned.
Keywords
"Qur'anic sciences and Hadith"
"structure"
"appearance"
"content"
"criticism"

Subjects

  1. Arambrastr, B. B., & Anderson, T. H. (1993). Tahlil ketab darsi (Hashem Fardaneshi, tarjome). _Nashriyeh Talim va Tarbiyat_, _33_.

 

  1. Armand, Mohammad, & Maleki, Hasan. (2012). _Moqaddame-i bar shive-ye tarahi va talife ketab darsi daneshgahi._ Tehran: Samt.

 

  1. Asghari, Mohammad, Lonia, Azaar, & Hasanzadeh, Ibrahimi. (2018). _Alghoye-ye negarish ketab amoozeshi: Tadvin, tanzim, virayesh, safheh-arayi, chap._ Tehran: Nashr, Tarashe Danesh.

 

  1. Pakatchi, Ahmad. (2017). _Ravesh tahqiq omumi ba rukorod olume insani - islami_ (4th ed.). Tehran: Daneshgah-e Imam Sadeq (A).

 

  1. Chenari, Amir. (2013). _Ain-negarish va virayesh baraye matun-e elmi, edari va matboo'ati_ (2nd ed.). Tehran: Zavar.

 

  1. Hatam, Sajjad, & Zineli, Ali. (2017). _Barname-ye darsi dore-ye ebtedayi_ (1st ed.). Mashhad: Aristoo.

 

  1. Hasanvandi, Mohsen, & Marvati, Sohrab. (2022). "Barrasi va naqdi ketab tahlil enteghadi angare tarjome-ye Quran Karim." _Dofaslnameh Elmi - Pazhooheshi Pazhoohesh va Negarish Ketu' Daneshgahi_, _48_.

 

  1. Rahiminajad, Vida. (2023). "Arzyabi va naqdi keyfiyat ketab darsi daneshgahi «Namayeshname-ye Gharne 17 ta 20» bar asaas-e ma'yar-e dah-gane Mansourian." _Dofaslnameh Elmi - Pazhooheshi Pazhoohesh va Negarish Ketu' Daneshgahi_, _52_.

 

  1. Rostaminajad, Mohammad Ali, Zangoyi, Asad Allah, Sharifi Nasab, Sadegh, & Shokoohi Fard, Hossein. (2014). "Ta'sir qalam huruf (font) bar sor'at, dark matn va deqat khandegan kutub darsi." _Dofaslnameh Elmi - Pazhooheshi Pazhoohesh va Negarish Ketu' Daneshgahi_, _34_.

 

  1. Rasooli, Mahasti, & Atashani, Zahra. (2014). _Tahlil mohtava ba rukord kutub darsi._ Tehran: Jame'-shenasan.

 

  1. Rezayi, Hamid, Hosseini Nia, Akbarnizhad, Mehdi, Hosseini, & Seyed Bashir. (2023). "Mo'alefehaye jazabiyat resanai dar araye mohtava-ye Quran Karim." _Faslnameh Elmi - Pazhooheshi Sabk-e Zendegi Islami ba Mahooriyat Salamat_, _1_.

 

  1. Zarrinkoub, Abdolhossein. (2020). _Ashnaii ba naqd adabi_ (10th ed.). Tehran: Sokhan.

 

  1. Ghasemi, Hamid, Kashkar, Sara, & Izadparast, Leila. (2021). _Ravesh‌شناسی naqdi va barrasi ketab_ (4th ed.). Tehran: Jame'-shenasan.

 

  1. Ghoramaki, Ahad Faramarz. (2004). _Osool va fonun pazhoohesh dar gostare-ye din-pazhoohi._ Qom: Markaz-e Modiriyat Houze-ye Elmiye Qom.

 

  1. Goruh-e Dastur Khat Farsi. (2022). _Dastur Khat Farsi._ Tehran: Farhangestan Zaban va Adab Farsi.

 

  1. Ma'aref, Majid, & Shari'ati Niyasir, Hamed. (2020). _Hendse-ye Daneshhaye Qorani, Hadisi._ Qom: Dar al-Hadith.

 

  1. Mansourian, Yazdan. (2013). "Sad vizhegi ketabhaye daneshgahi." _Dofaslnameh Elmi - Pazhooheshi Pazhoohesh va Negarish Ketu' Daneshgahi_, _29_.

 

  1. Mandi, Jeremy. (2012). _M'arif-i mato'l-ta'alemat_tarjome_ (Ali Bahrami & Zeinab Tajik, Tedjome). Tehran: Rahnama.

 

  1. Nokunam, Jafar. (2010). _Ravesh tahqiq ba ta'kid bar olume islami._ Qom: Entesharat Daneshgah Qom.

 

  1. Norouzi, Alireza. (2001). _Namayeh-sazi ketab: Rahnamayi baraye nashran, namayeh-sazan, ketabdaran, mo'alefan va motarjeman._ Tehran: Chapar.

 

  1. Berman, A. (1999). _La Traduction et la Lettre ou L’auberge du Lointain._ Les tours de Babel. Paris: Seuil.

 

  1. Supaphol, P. (2010). Ethics in scientific writing. _Chiang Mai Journal of Science, 37_(2).

 

  1. Vicinus, M., & Eisner, C. (2009). _Originality, imitation, and plagiarism: Teaching writing in the digital age_ (p. 281).

 

---