University Textbooks; Research and Writting

University Textbooks; Research and Writting

Retrieval of the Ideological Strategies in the University Textbooks, A Study of Textbooks on Medieval Iran History

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors
1 PhD Student in General Linguistics, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
2 Associate Professor, The Institute for Research and Development in the Humanities, SAMT
3 Assistant Professor of Department of History of Shahid Beheshti University
Abstract
The present study aims to introduce a methodological model for the critical reading of history university textbooks through identifying ideological strategies in these texts. The retrieval of these components shows that although authors use some expressive techniques to provide a realistic representation of historical actors and events in the medieval period of Iran history, in practice, they transfer certain evaluative attitudes and readings from the past to their readers. Using Van Dijk’s discourse analysis tools, this paper aims to present an explanatory and descriptive approach towards the normal attitudes of the native and non-native authors to the history of Iran in the Samanid, Ghaznavid, Saljuqid, and Qarakhanid periods. For this purpose, the four above dynasties that have been reflected in four native textbooks and two non-native reference books – as data corpus – were quantitatively and comparatively reviewed. Therefore, the native and non-native history books were studied in terms of the ideological strategies that have been applied in their meaning, style and syntax. According to the statistics, it became clear that the use of ideological strategies is inevitable in history narration. Also, by analyzing the ideological strategies in the text, it became clear that the differences that exist in the views of the Iranian and foreign authors as “us” and “them” towards Iranian history can affect the reading and representation of the historical events. In the narration of the native history writers more emphasis is placed on the positive characteristics of Iranians, such as their braveries and valiances, while in the writings of non-narrative writers, their negative qualities, such as class differences and the conflicts between Iranian ethnic groups, are reflected.
Keywords

Hiden, White (2002). Methistory,The Historical in Sixth Century Europe, The John Hopkins University Press.
Larmon, Janine and Lea Graham (2015). “Teaching Historical Through Creative Writing Assignments”, Journal Home Page, London: Routledge.
Ludvigsson, David and Alan Booth (2015). Enriching History Teaching and Learning, Linkoping University.
Moreau, Joseph (2011). School Book Nation, Conflicts over American History Textbooks from the Civil War to the Present, The University of Michigan Press Ann Arbor.
Peterson and Graham (2015). Teaching Critical Thinking in History, University Analysis of Chicago Press.
Scott David and Usher Robin (2011). Researching Education, 2nd ed., NewYork: Press.
Van Dijk (1997). Discourse and Manipulation, London: Sage Publication.
Van Dijk and A. Teun (2000). Ideology a Multidisciplimary Approach, London: Sage Publication.
Van Dijk and A. Teun (2004). Ideology and Discourse, London: Sage Publication.
Wretch, James (2016). A Semantic Analysis of Historians Language, TheHangu Press.
Ahmadi hosain. (1391) The study of Azarbiejan History Text books. Tehran. Peyman cultural journal. No 59 . [In Persian]
Seyamian Gorji Zohair. (1392). Salehi Korosh. Critical Study of Representation of Iran Evolutions in Ale Boye age in the University Text books. Pajohesh and negaresh kotob daneshgahi. No 28. P 62-76. [In Persian]
Fery. R.N.(1385).Iran History from Disintegration Sasaniyan to Coming Saljogian. Amir kabir Press. Fourth volume. [In Persian]
Forozani Seyed Abolgasem. (1390). The Political, Social, Economical and Cultural of Iran Evolutions in Sasaniyan age. Samt Press. [In Persian]
Mick Yan.(1393). The Studying and  Writing of Text books. Translated by Moradzadeh and Golshahi. Samt Press. [In Persian]