University Textbooks; Research and Writting

University Textbooks; Research and Writting

A Critical Case Sampling of Seven Textbooks on "Criminal Policy"; A Research on the Void of Legal Books Bibliometric

Document Type : Research Paper

Author
Mahdi Khaghani Esfahani
Assistant Professor of Criminal Law & Criminology, the Institute for Research and Development in the Humanities (SAMT), Tehran, Iran.
10.30487/rwab.2025.2048364.1633
Abstract
Criminal policy is a new criminal science that emerges from the interaction of public policy and criminal law, and is focused on adopting systemic strategies to control crime and deviant risks. Given that realistic and monitorable criminal policymaking is not possible without analyzing the obstacles to the access of this knowledge and its manifestations in the Iranian criminal justice system, this article, using a targeted case study method, has subjected ten seven prominent Iranian books on criminal policy, out of 50 academic academic books published in this field of criminal science, to content and structural criticism, and conventional methodologies in legal book criticism research, regardless of their commitment to quantitative data mining and software analysis with a purposeful sampling method based on a descriptive-analytical model. According to the hypothesis that the continued publication of writings that are inconsistent with the principles and structure of criminal policy in the name of criminal policy prevents the exploitation of the historical opportunity created by the positive approach of the new curriculum for the master's and doctoral degrees in criminal law and criminology (approved by the Iranian Ministry of Science in 2022 and 2023) to the knowledge of criminal policy, the present article focuses on the bibliometric method of "Criminal Policy" is the first Iranian research on bibliometrics of "criminal policy" academic books, which, in the absence of codified indicators for criminological research outputs suggests criteria for writing a academic books on criminal policy , .....
Keywords
academic books
book bibliometric
book reviews
criminal science research
criminal policy

Subjects

  1. Akbari, M.; Ghannad, F. (1395), Pasokhe Dolati be Enheraf dar Siyasate Jenaie Iran. Tehran: Majd.

    Translation: Akbari, M.; Ghannad, F. (2016), Government Response to Deviation in Iran’s Criminal Policy. Tehran: Majd.

  2. Iravanian, A. (1392), Nazariye Omumiye Siyasatgozariye Jenaie. Tehran: Pazhooheshkadeye Hoghughiye Shahr-e Danesh.

    Translation: Iravanian, A. (2013), General Theory of Criminal Policymaking. Tehran: Shahr-e Danesh Legal Research Center.

  3. Iman, M. T.; Kalateh Sadati, A. (1391), “Asibshenasiye Roshe Toseeye Olume Ensani dar Iran”. Rahbord-e Farhang, 5(19): 27-51.

    Translation: Iman, M. T.; Kalateh Sadati, A. (2012), “Pathology of the Method of Human Sciences Development in Iran.” Cultural Strategy, 5(19): 27-51.

  4. Parastesh, R., Mousavizadeh Markiyeh, S. Sh. (1397), “Tahavvole Siyasate Jenaie Ghazaei dar Partoye Roikarde Farhangi”, Pazhooheshnameye Hoghugh-e Keyfari, 9(1): 7-31.

    Translation: Parastesh, R., Mousavizadeh Markiyeh, S. Sh. (2018), “The Evolution of Judicial Criminal Policy in Light of the Cultural Approach,” Journal of Criminal Law Research, 9(1): 7-31.

  5. Peighami, A., Sajadiye, A. (1393), “Elzamat va Khat-Mashihaye Kalane Elmiye Arseye Edalat Pazhuhi dar Andisheye Maghame Moazzame Rahbari”. Andisheye Modiriyate Rahbordi, 8(2): 29-30.

    Translation: Peighami, A., Sajadiye, A. (2014), “Requirements and Macro Scientific Policies of the Field of Justice Research in the Thought of the Supreme Leader.” Strategic Management Thought, 8(2): 29-30.

  6. Pinatel, J. (1402), Jormshenasi, tarjomeye Reza Olumi. Tehran: Adl-e Ghanoon.

    Translation: Pinatel, J. (2023), Criminology, translated by Reza Olumi. Tehran: Adl-e Ghanoon (Justice of Law).

  7. Taghizadeh, M., Nobahar, R., Gholami Doon, H. (1398), “Mabanie Arzyabiye Siyasate Jenaie”. Motaleate Hoghugh-e Keyfari va Jormshenasi, 49(2): 353-371.

    Translation: Taghizadeh, M., Nobahar, R., Gholami Doon, H. (2019), “Foundations of Criminal Policy Evaluation.” Studies in Criminal Law and Criminology, 49(2): 353-371.

  8. Jamshidi, A. (1390), Siyasate Jenaie Mosharekati. Tehran: Mizan.

    Translation: Jamshidi, A. (2011), Participatory Criminal Policy. Tehran: Mizan (Balance).

  9. Javadi, M., Danaeifard, H. (1397), “Shenasaei va Asibshenasiye Charchube Hokmraniye Pazhoohesh dar Olume Ensani dar Jomhuriye Islamiye Iran”. Rahbord, 27(87): 61-86.

    Translation: Javadi, M., Danaeifard, H. (2018), “Identification and Pathology of the Research Governance Framework in the Humanities in the Islamic Republic of Iran.” Strategy, 27(87): 61-86.

  10. Hasani, S. H., Rafiei, S. H., Bakhshi Ani, A. (1395), “Barrasiye Naghshe Sazmanhaaye Pazhoohesh va Fanavari dar Nezame Melliye Novavari”. Siyasate Elm va Fanavari, 8(4): 63-76.

    Translation: Hasani, S. H., Rafiei, S. H., Bakhshi Ani, A. (2016), “Investigating the Role of Research and Technology Organizations in the National Innovation System.” Science and Technology Policy, 8(4): 63-76.

  11. Hosseini Nik, S. A. (1392), Siyasat-e Jenaie Iran dar Hemayat az Hoghugh-e Talif va Nashr. Tehran: Majd.

    Translation: Hosseini Nik, S. A. (2013), Iran’s Criminal Policy in Support of Copyright and Publication Rights. Tehran: Majd.

  12. Khaghani Esfahani, M. (1403), “Naghde Sabke Gostaresh-e Neveshtegan-e Daneshgahie Siyasat-e Jenaie”. Pazhoohesh va Negaresh-e Kotob-e Daneshgahi, EnteShare Online az 3/10/1403.

    Translation: Khaghani Esfahani, M. (2024), “Critique of the Style of Expanding Academic Writings on Criminal Policy.” Research and Writing of University Books, Published Online from 12/23/2024.

  13. Khaghani Esfahani, M. (1401), “Doshvareye Taamol-e Nass va Vagheiyat dar Barsakht-e Siyasat-e Jenaie Islami”. Siyasatgozariye Umumi, 8(3): 79-92.

    Translation: Khaghani Esfahani, M. (2022), “The Difficulty of Interaction Between Text and Reality in the Construction of Islamic Criminal Policy.” Public Policy, 8(3): 79-92.

  14. Delmas-Marty, M. (1402), Nezamhaye Bozorge Siyasat-e Jenaie, tarjomeye Ali Hossein Najafi Abrandabadi, virayeshe panjom, Tehran: Mizan.

    Translation: Delmas-Marty, M. (2023), Major Criminal Justice Systems, translated by Ali Hossein Najafi Abrandabadi, fifth edition, Tehran: Mizan.

  15. Zahed Zahedani, S. S. (1397), “Naghde Ketabe Jameeye Madani va Demokrasi dar Khavarmianeh”, Pazhooheshnameye Enteghadiye Motun va Barnamehaye Olume Ensani, 18(12): 157-180.

    Translation: Zahed Zahedani, S. S. (2018), “Critique of the Book ‘Civil Society and Democracy in the Middle East’,” Critical Research Journal of Human Sciences Texts and Programs, 18(12): 157-180.

  16. Zandi, T. (1402), “Tadvine va Etebar Yayabiye Charchubi baraye Tarrahi va Tolid-e Ketab-e Darsi-ye Daneshgahie Electronic”, Pazhoohesh va Negaresh-e Kotob-e Daneshgahi, 27(53): 32-61.

    Translation: Zandi, T. (2023), “Formulating and Validating a Framework for Designing and Producing an Electronic University Textbook,” Research and Writing of University Books, 27(53): 32-61.

  17. Suriamurthi, R. (1402), Elmsanji baraye Olume Ensani va Ejtemaei. tarjomeye Ghasem Azadi Ahmadabadi va Mahmoud Sangari, Tehran: Chapar.

    Translation: Suriamurthi, R. (2023), Scientometrics for the Humanities and Social Sciences. translated by Ghasem Azadi Ahmadabadi and Mahmoud Sangari, Tehran: Chapar.

  18. Shamloo, B. (1403), Siyasat-e Jenaie. Tehran: Mizan.

    Translation: Shamloo, B. (2024), Criminal Policy. Tehran: Mizan.

  19. Shahabadi, A., Salimi, S. (1394), “Tassire Hokmraniye Khub bar Seddate Tahghigh va Toseeye Keshvarhaye Montakhabe Tosee Yaafte va dar Hale Tosee”, Siyasate Elm va Fanavari, 7(2): 35-46.

    Translation: Shahabadi, A., Salimi, S. (2015), “The Impact of Good Governance on the Intensity of Research and Development of Selected Developed and Developing Countries,” Science and Technology Policy, 7(2): 35-46.

  20. Shiri, A. (1397), “Siyasatgozariye Jenaie, az Control-e Daruni ta Control-e Biruni-ye Jorm”, Siyasatgozariye Umumi, 4(3): 103-121.

    Translation: Shiri, A. (2018), “Criminal Policymaking, from Internal Control to External Control of Crime,” Public Policy, 4(3): 103-121.

  21. Arefi, M., Habibzadeh, M. J., Omidi, J., Farajiha, M. (1398), “Bastarhaye Modakhele Keyfari dar Hoze-ye Fagh; az Siyasate Jang ba Fagh ta Siyasate Jang ba Foghara”. Pazhoohesh-e Hoghugh-e Keyfari, 7(26): 75-107.

    Translation: Arefi, M., Habibzadeh, M. J., Omidi, J., Farajiha, M. (2019), “The Contexts of Criminal Intervention in the Field of Poverty; from the Policy of War on Poverty to the Policy of War on the Poor.” Criminal Law Research, 7(26): 75-107.

  22. Ameri Sani, A. (1403), Siyasatgozariye Jenaie Masaleh Mehvar dar Jomhuriye Islamiye Iran. Tehran: Mizan.

    Translation: Ameri Sani, A. (2024), Problem-Oriented Criminal Policymaking in the Islamic Republic of Iran. Tehran: Mizan.

  23. Erfanmanesh, M. A., Morovati, M. (1395), “Motaleeye Elmsanji va Tahlile Shabakeye Hamkarihaye Elmi dar Faslnameye Motaleate Miyan Reshtei dar Olume Ensani”, Motaleate Miyan Reshtei dar Olume Ensani. 8(4): 55-77.

    Translation: Erfanmanesh, M. A., Morovati, M. (2016), “A Scientometric Study and Analysis of the Network of Scientific Collaborations in the Interdisciplinary Studies in the Humanities Quarterly,” Interdisciplinary Studies in the Humanities. 8(4): 55-77.

  24. Alizadeh, Y., Ghoreishi Mohammadi, F. S. (1402), “Salahiyate Shoraye Helle Ekhtelaf az Manzare Dadresiye Akhlaghi va Adelaneh”. Akhlagh dar Olum va Fanavari, 18(4): 63-68.

    Translation: Alizadeh, Y., Ghoreishi Mohammadi, F. S. (2023), “The Jurisdiction of Dispute Resolution Councils from the Perspective of Ethical and Fair Trial.” Ethics in Science and Technology, 18(4): 63-68.

  25. Ghaffari, H. (1391), “Nesbat Miyan Hakemiyate Share va Hakemiyate Ghanoon dar Nezame Ghazaiye Jomhuriye Islamiye Iran”. Pazhoohesh-e Hoghugh-e Umumi, 14(36): 107-132.

    Translation: Ghaffari, H. (2012), “The Relationship Between the Rule of Sharia and the Rule of Law in the Judicial System of the Islamic Republic of Iran.” Public Law Research, 14(36): 107-132.

  26. Ghasemian, A., Asnafi, A. R., Erfanmanesh, M. A. (1402), “Arzyabiye Burundadhaye Pazhooheshiye Daneshgahe Shahide Beheshti dar Hoze-ye Olume Ejtemaei va Raftari ba Estefade az Shakhshihaye Elmsanji va Digarsanji”. Pazhooheshnameye Elmsanji, 9(1): 211-230.

    Translation: Ghasemian, A., Asnafi, A. R., Erfanmanesh, M. A. (2023), “Evaluation of Research Outputs of Shahid Beheshti University in the Field of Social and Behavioral Sciences Using Scientometric and Altmetric Indicators.” Journal of Scientometrics Research, 9(1): 211-230.

  27. Koonani, S., Ansari, J., Mandani, I. (1393), Siyasat-e Jenaie; az Gofteman ta Barsakht-e Rhizomic Shodeh va Narava. Tehran: Majd.

    Translation: Koonani, S., Ansari, J., Mandani, I. (2014), Criminal Policy; From Discourse to Rhizomic and Illicit Construction. Tehran: Majd.

  28. Lazerges, C. (1400), Daramadi be Siyasat-e Jenaie. tarjomeye Ali Hossein Najafi Abrandabadi, Chape Dahom, Tehran: Mizan.

    Translation: Lazerges, C. (2021), An Introduction to Criminal Policy. translated by Ali Hossein Najafi Abrandabadi, Tenth Edition, Tehran: Mizan.

  29. Mozhdehi Fard, M., Milani, A. (1398), Jaygahe Edalate Termimi dar Siyasate Jenaie Ghazaeiye Jomhuriye Islamiye Iran dar Dadresiye Atfal va Nojavanan, Tehran: Majd.

    Translation: Mozhdehi Fard, M., Milani, A. (2019), The Place of Restorative Justice in the Judicial Criminal Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran in Juvenile Justice, Tehran: Majd.

  30. Masoumi Nejad, R., Madadlou, G., Khezrzadeh, K., Heshmati, Kh. (1402), “Vakaviye Shakhshehaye Puchzodaie az Barnamehaye Darsi dar Rastaye Ghanisaziye Mohtavaye Ketabhaye Darsiye Daneshgah Farhangian”, Pazhoohesh va Negaresh-e Kotob-e Daneshgahi, 27(53): 1-31.

    Translation: Masoumi Nejad, R., Madadlou, G., Khezrzadeh, K., Heshmati, Kh. (2023), “Investigating the Characteristics of Meaning Extraction from Curricula in Order to Enrich the Content of Textbooks of Farhangian University,” Research and Writing of University Books, 27(53): 1-31.

  31. Malek-ol-Kalami, M., Hassanzadeh, M., Sharif, A., Rezghi Ahaghi, M. (1402), “Tahlile Khusheiye Toseeye Danesh dar Hoze-ye Estekhraje Danesh dar Sanaaye Khedmati”. Pazhooheshnameye Elmsanji, 9(2): 445-470.

    Translation: Malek-ol-Kalami, M., Hassanzadeh, M., Sharif, A., Rezghi Ahaghi, M. (2023), “Cluster Analysis of Knowledge Development in the Field of Knowledge Extraction in Service Industries.” Journal of Scientometrics Research, 9(2): 445-470.

  32. Najafi Tavana, A. (1389), Siyasat-e Jenaie (Majmueye Maghalat). Tehran: Amoozesh va Sanjesh.

    Translation: Najafi Tavana, A. (2010), Criminal Policy (Collection of Articles). Tehran: Amoozesh va Sanjesh (Education and Assessment).

  33. Nourbaha, R. (1378), “Siyasat-e Jenaie Sargardan”, Tahghighat-e Hoghughi, 2(25-26): 103-127.

    Translation: Nourbaha, R. (1999), “Wandering Criminal Policy,” Legal Research, 2(25-26): 103-127.