پژوهش و نگارش کتب دانشگاهی

پژوهش و نگارش کتب دانشگاهی

متن روایی به‌مثابه متن نظری: امکان‌سنجی آموزشی رمان آمریکناه با تکیه بر نظریه فضای سوم بابا برای دروس فرهنگ و پسااستعمار

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسنده
دانشیار زبان و ادبیات انگلیسی ، دانشگاه مازندران
10.30487/rwab.2026.2104684.1705
چکیده
در پاسخ به نیاز روزافزون به منابع آموزشی میان‌رشته‌ای و تجربه‌محور در آموزش مفاهیم پیچیده فرهنگی، این پژوهش به امکان‌سنجی استفاده از رمان «آمریکناه» به‌عنوان متنی مکمل در تدریس مطالعات پسااستعماری و فرهنگی در دانشگاه پرداخته است. «ظرفیت آموزشی» شامل مؤلفه‌های محتوایی (هم‌راستایی مضامین رمان با مفاهیم نظری)، ساختاری (ویژگی‌های روایی و شخصیت‌پردازی)، تعاملی (پتانسیل بحث و مشارکت دانشجویان) و یادگیری (عینی‌سازی مفاهیم انتزاعی و تقویت تفکر انتقادی) است. این پژوهش کیفی با تحلیل مضمون بر اساس الگوی شش‌مرحله‌ای براون و کلارک (2006) انجام شده است. کل رمان به‌عنوان پیکره پژوهش در نظر گرفته شد و بخش‌های مرتبط با هویت، مهاجرت، نژاد، تعامل فرهنگی و روابط قدرت برای تحلیل تفصیلی انتخاب شدند. کدگذاری به‌صورت ترکیبی قیاسی ـ استقرایی انجام شد؛ مفاهیم نظری بابا به‌عنوان مقوله‌های اولیه و کدهای توصیفی جدید به‌صورت استقرایی از متن استخراج شدند. یافته‌ها نشان می‌دهد آمریکناه با روایت‌های عینی از مواجهه با نژاد، تبعیض، سیالیت فرهنگی و هویت‌های تراملی، بستری ملموس برای درک نظریه‌های انتزاعی، تقویت تحلیل موقعیت، افزایش حساسیت میان‌فرهنگی و پیوند نظریه با زیست‑جهان دانشجویان فراهم می‌سازد. ظرفیت‌های دراماتیک و گفت‌وگومحور رمان نیز فعالیت‌هایی چون نقش‌آفرینی، مناظره و نگارش تأملی را تسهیل می‌کند. با این حال، کاربست مؤثر این متن نیازمند بسته‌های آموزشی هدفمند، کارگاه‌های توانمندسازی اساتید و انعطاف‌پذیری در برنامه‌درسی متناسب با زمینه‌های بومی است. پژوهش نتیجه می‌گیرد آمریکناه می‌تواند به‌عنوان متن مکمل در تدریس مطالعات پسااستعماری و فرهنگی در دانشگاه‌های ایران به کار رود.
کلیدواژه‌ها
موضوعات

عنوان مقاله English

Narrative as Theory: Assessing the Pedagogical Feasibility of Americanah through Bhabha's Third Space Concept for Courses in Culture and Postcolonial Studies

نویسنده English

Behzad Pourgharib
Associate Professor of English Language and Literature University of Mazandaran, Iran
چکیده English

Abstract
In response to the growing need for interdisciplinary and experience-based educational resources in teaching complex cultural concepts, this study examines the feasibility of using the novel Americanah as a supplementary text in teaching postcolonial and cultural studies at the university level. "Educational capacity" comprises content-related components (alignment of the novel's themes with theoretical concepts), structural components (narrative and characterization features), interactive components (potential for discussion and student participation), and learning-related components (concretizing abstract concepts and fostering critical thinking). This qualitative study employed thematic analysis based on Braun and Clarke's (2006) six-phase model. The entire novel was considered as the research corpus, and sections related to identity, migration, race, cultural interaction, and power relations were selected for detailed analysis. Coding was conducted in a combined deductive–inductive manner; Bhabha's theoretical concepts served as initial categories, while new descriptive codes were inductively extracted from the text. The findings indicate that Americanah, through its concrete narratives of encounters with race, discrimination, cultural fluidity, and transnational identities, provides a tangible ground for understanding abstract theories, strengthening situated analysis, increasing intercultural sensitivity, and linking theory to students' lifeworlds. The novel's dramatic and dialogic capacities also facilitate activities such as role-playing, debate, and reflective writing. However, the effective use of this text requires targeted educational packages, faculty empowerment workshops, and flexibility in curriculum design suited to local cultural contexts. The study concludes that Americanah can be used as a supplementary text in teaching postcolonial and cultural studies at Iranian universities.

Introduction
In recent decades, the turn toward interdisciplinary and experience-based approaches in higher education have prompted a reconsideration of the role of literary texts in teaching complex cultural concepts. Literature is increasingly recognized not merely as an object of aesthetic appreciation but as a pedagogical resource capable of making abstract theoretical constructs tangible, situated, and personally meaningful for students. In particular, postcolonial literature has acquired a distinctive position in this regard, because it engages directly with the experiences of migration, racial discrimination, displacement, and the formation of hybrid identities, thereby providing a bridge between theory and lived experience. Scholars in curriculum studies have argued that educational resources should move beyond the mere transmission of theoretical knowledge and should instead create opportunities for active participation, dialogue, and critical thinking.
Despite this growing recognition, the use of literary narratives as supplementary pedagogical resources in Iranian higher education remains limited. Instruction in postcolonial and cultural studies in Iranian universities has tended to rely heavily on theoretical texts, which—while indispensable—can make the learning of abstract concepts difficult for students and can impede the connection between theory and lived experience. This gap has motivated the search for resources that can concretize theoretical concepts and enhance student engagement.
Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie's novel Americanah (2013), one of the most significant works of contemporary African literature, addresses themes of migration, race, hybridity, cultural translation, and the formation of diasporic identities. These themes make it a potentially suitable resource for teaching the foundational concepts of cultural and postcolonial studies. The novel recounts the intertwined lives of Ifemelu and Obinze, two young Nigerians whose trajectories of migration to the United States and the United Kingdom, and their eventual return to Nigeria, illuminate the complex dynamics of race, class, gender, and cultural belonging in the contemporary world.
The theoretical framework of the study draws on Homi K. Bhabha's postcolonial theory, particularly the concepts of cultural hybridity, the third space, and mimicry. Bhabha conceptualizes identity as a dynamic and fluid phenomenon that is continuously reshaped through the interaction of cultures and historical experiences. From this perspective, literary texts that represent the experience of migration and cultural encounter can serve as pedagogical instruments for objectifying the abstract concepts of postcolonial theory and for deepening students' understanding of the complex relations of power, identity, and culture in the contemporary world.
The present study aims to systematically assess the pedagogical capacity of Americanah for teaching the concepts of cultural and postcolonial studies in Iranian higher education. It addresses three principal research questions: First, to what extent can Americanah be used as a supplementary resource in teaching cultural and postcolonial studies? Second, what are the most important pedagogical components of the novel based on Bhabha's theory? Third, what opportunities and challenges accompany the use of this work in the Iranian higher education system? By answering these questions, the study seeks to introduce the novel's potential for teaching postcolonial studies in Iranian universities and to offer a model for using literary works as interdisciplinary tools in the humanities.

Research Methodology
This study is qualitative in nature and employs a descriptive-analytical approach. The text of the novel was analyzed using thematic analysis following the six-phase model of Braun and Clarke (2006). In the first phase, the text of the novel was read several times in full, and notes were made on points relevant to the research questions and theoretical concepts. In the second phase, initial coding was conducted across the text, and sections related to identity, migration, race, discrimination, cultural interaction, language, power, and cultural belonging were identified. In the third phase, related codes were organized into initial themes based on conceptual similarity. In the fourth phase, the initial themes were reviewed both at the level of the data and in relation to the novel as a whole. In the fifth phase, the final themes were defined and named, and the conceptual scope of each theme was specified. In the sixth phase, the findings were interpreted and reported in terms of the relationship among textual evidence, theoretical concepts, and the pedagogical capacity of the novel.
Coding was conducted in a combined deductive-inductive manner. Bhabha's theoretical concepts—including hybridity, the third space, and mimicry—were used as initial categories, while new descriptive codes such as belonging, racial labeling, cultural adaptation, language, displacement, and identity negotiation were inductively extracted from the text. In the coding process, a total of twenty-six initial codes were identified based on textual units and narrative evidence. After merging conceptually similar codes, reviewing them, and continuously comparing them with the text and the theoretical framework, these codes were organized into twelve sub-themes. In the next stage, the sub-themes were organized into five main themes: "identity and cultural hybridity," "the third space and cultural negotiation," "othering and power relations," "agency and ambivalence of identity," and "the pedagogical capacity of the text." These main themes were interpreted in relation to the research questions and the four operational components of pedagogical capacity: content, structural, interactive, and learning components.
The study population consisted of theoretical and applied studies published on Americanah, Bhabha's postcolonial theory, and the teaching of literature and cultural studies. The sample was purposively selected. The unit of analysis comprised passages from the novel—narratives, character dialogues, and descriptions related to the experience of migration, race, discrimination, cultural interaction, and the representation of identity. The criterion for selecting these passages was their direct relevance to the research questions and Bhabha's theoretical concepts. To enhance the validity and reliability of the findings, the strategy of source triangulation was employed. The results were compared with Persian-language studies—such as Pourgharib and Esmaili (2023)—and with international studies related to Americanah in order to determine convergence and divergence. In addition, Costa's (2019) view on the role of literature in developing intercultural competence and Hollertz's (2018) view on increasing students' cultural awareness through the study of postcolonial literary works were used to interpret the pedagogical capacities of the novel. The coding and theme-extraction process was reviewed several times, and the final themes were compared with the main text of the novel and the findings of previous research. Finally, triangulation of theoretical sources and previous studies was employed to ensure consistency between the textual data and the theoretical framework and to increase the validity of the interpretation.

Discussion
The Novel's Representation of Hybridity, Third Space, and Identity Reconstruction
The thematic analysis of Americanah shows that the most important pedagogical capacity of the work lies in its representation of the process of identity reconstruction in the context of migration and intercultural interaction. An examination of the trajectory of the character Ifemelu reveals that her identity is not static or predetermined but is gradually transformed through continuous encounter with the new social environment, the experience of racial discrimination, changes in self-perception, and interaction with the host culture. Migration in this novel is not merely a spatial displacement but a process that compels the character to rethink her individual, cultural, and social identity. From this perspective, the novel's narrative enables students to observe the process of identity formation concretely and to move theoretical concepts from the level of abstraction to the level of lived experience.
A clear example of this transformation appears in Ifemelu's reflection on her racial identity: "I came from a country where race was not an issue; I did not think of myself as black and I only became black when I came to America" (Adichie, 2013, p. 288). This statement shows that racial identity is not an essential feature but a social construct formed through interaction with the cultural and political structures of the host society. From the perspective of Bhabha's theory, this experience can be explained through the concepts of cultural hybridity and the third space. Ifemelu neither completely abandons her Nigerian identity nor fully assimilates into American culture; rather, she creates a composite and dynamic identity in the space between the two cultures. The novel thus provides students with a concrete example of Bhabha's theoretical concepts and enables them to understand these concepts in practical terms.
This finding is consistent with the results of Rezaei and Asadi Amjad (2022), who compared Bhabha's and Edward Said's views and showed that migrant identity in the intercultural space is continuously redefined and that resistance to dominant discourses becomes possible. It is also consistent with the findings of Khazaei and Karnava-Torabi (2021), who concluded that migration in contemporary literature leads not so much to complete self-alienation as to the formation of composite and multilayered identities. In the international context, the finding aligns with Rokaya (2023), who regards Ifemelu as an example of a postcolonial subject who continuously reconstructs her identity in the space between Nigerian and American cultures, and with Shamshad and Hashmi (2022), who argue that cultural hybridity not only creates identity challenges but also enables the formation of cultural agency.
Othering, Power Relations, and the Critique of Racial Hierarchies
Another important pedagogical capacity of the novel is its representation of othering and power relations. The novel depicts the racial hierarchy of American society and the ways in which immigrants are labeled, stereotyped, and positioned within a racial order. Ifemelu's observation of the four types of tribalism in America—class, ideology, region, and race—provides a concrete illustration of the social structures that shape the experience of migrants:
In America, tribalism is alive and well. There are four kinds—class, ideology, region, and race. First, class. Pretty easy. Rich and poor. Second, ideology. Liberals and conservatives. They not only disagree on political issues, each side believes the other is evil. Intermarriage is discouraged and on the rare occasions that it happens, it is considered noteworthy. Third, region. The North and the South. The two sides fought a civil war and the scars remain. The North looks down on the South while the South resents the North. Finally, race. There's a ladder of racial hierarchy in America. White is always on top, specifically White Anglo-Saxon Protestant, otherwise known as WASP, and American Black is always on the bottom, and what's in the middle depends on time and place. (Adichie, 2013, p. 187)
This perception of American social structure shows that the protagonist is situated in a third space in which she must understand new rules and boundaries and redefine her identity in interaction with systems of social and racial classification. Motahane (2025) argues that Americanah, by representing power relations and racial discrimination, provides a basis for critiquing social and cultural structures. The findings of the present study also show that Ifemelu's experiences in American society familiarize students with the mechanisms that produce discrimination and inequality.
A further example appears in the novel's treatment of the experience of being racialized: "In America, you are black, baby" (Adichie, 2013, p. 221). This passage shows how non-American immigrants are subjected to othering and racial labeling and how their identity is redefined in the new space. Rokaya (2023) regards Ifemelu as an example of a postcolonial subject who continuously reconstructs her identity in the intercultural space. This reconstruction is also evident in Ifemelu's reflection on her romantic relationship with Curt, where she observes that race does not matter when they are alone but becomes salient as soon as they step outside: "The only reason you say that race was not an issue is because you wish it was not. We all wish it was not. But it's a lie. I came from a country where race was not an issue; I did not think of myself as black and I only became black when I came to America" (Adichie, 2013, pp. 288–289). This passage shows how awareness of hybrid identity is formed in the postcolonial space and how interracial love, despite the possibility of intercultural dialogue, continues to face the challenges of othering. Shamshad and Hashmi (2022) conclude that cultural hybridity is not only a source of identity crisis but also enables the formation of cultural agency and resistance to dominant discourses. This interpretation is also observable in the analysis of the novel's characters, who achieve a redefinition of their cultural and social position through the experience of migration.
The Pedagogical Capacity of the Novel: Content, Structure, Interaction, and Learning
The findings of the thematic analysis indicate that Americanah possesses significant pedagogical capacity across four dimensions. In terms of content, the novel provides concrete examples of Bhabha's concepts—hybridity, the third space, mimicry, and othering—through the representation of Ifemelu's migration experience and her encounters with American racial and cultural structures. The textual evidence, such as the passages cited above, enables students to analyze abstract theoretical concepts in the context of a concrete literary narrative. In terms of structure, the novel's multilayered narrative and complex characterization—particularly the parallel trajectories of Ifemelu and Obinze—enable the analysis of character development in the context of migration and return. In terms of interaction, the novel's dramatic dialogues and situational conflicts provide opportunities for classroom discussion, debate, and role-playing. In terms of learning, the connection between theory and lived experience facilitates conceptual learning and the strengthening of critical thinking.
The study's findings are consistent with the results of previous research on the pedagogical use of Americanah in Western contexts. Ford (2017) reports that teaching the novel increases student participation in discussions of race, gender, and identity and enhances analytical skills. Hayes-Brady (2022) shows that dialogue about the novel's characters and situations deepens students' understanding of the relations among culture, power, and identity. Costa (2019) emphasizes the novel's role in developing intercultural competence and increasing cultural awareness. Hollertz (2018) presents the novel as a suitable basis for promoting cultural awareness and argues that its multidimensional characters enable identification and deeper understanding of the cultural other. Ramírez-Espinosa et al. (2019) emphasize the novel's role in fostering intercultural dialogue and bridging theory and practice in cultural studies. The present study's findings align with these results and confirm that the novel's narrative makes abstract concepts of postcolonial studies more accessible and applicable for students.
In the Persian-language literature, Pourgharib and Esmaili (2023) have shown that migratory narratives, through the representation of memory, trauma, and decolonization, enable a deeper understanding of cultural concepts. This finding is consistent with the present study, since Americanah also transforms the experience of migration into a basis for rethinking identity and cultural belonging. Pourgharib et al. (2023) have argued that the connection among narrative, memory, and identity makes the novel a suitable resource for teaching the concepts of diaspora, cultural identity, and postcolonial studies. The present study confirms this pedagogical capacity and shows that literary narrative can make theoretical concepts more tangible and applicable for students.
Opportunities and Challenges in the Iranian Higher Education Context
The use of Americanah in Iranian higher education is accompanied by both opportunities and challenges. The opportunities include the possibility of strengthening critical thinking, enhancing intercultural competence, improving the skills of literary analysis, and deepening students' understanding of identity, migration, and power relations. The novel can serve as a supplementary resource alongside traditional theoretical texts in courses on cultural studies, comparative literature, postcolonial studies, and language teaching. However, the effective use of the novel requires attention to several challenges. Karamati (2020) emphasizes the necessity of aligning educational resources with the objectives of the curriculum and the characteristics of the audience, and argues that the effectiveness of an educational resource depends on how it is designed and implemented in the classroom. Jamali Zavareh, Nasr, and Armand (2008) show that the use of new educational resources is successful only when accompanied by appropriate teaching strategies and active participation of learners. Accordingly, the cultural differences between Iranian society and the African context of the novel, the complexity of postcolonial theoretical concepts, and the need for instructors to be familiar with Bhabha's theoretical framework are among the most important challenges to the effective use of this novel. Therefore, the use of this work in university classrooms should be accompanied by the design of analytical activities, the introduction of the historical and cultural contexts of the novel, the development of teaching guides, and the use of participatory teaching methods so that students can establish a deep and meaningful connection between the literary narrative and the theoretical debates of cultural and postcolonial studies.

Conclusion
This study aimed to systematically assess the pedagogical capacity of Americanah for teaching the concepts of cultural and postcolonial studies in Iranian universities. "Pedagogical capacity" in this research refers to the internal potential of the text to support the learning process, not to its proven effectiveness in the classroom. This capacity was examined across four dimensions: content, structure, interaction, and learning. The results of the thematic analysis showed that Americanah, through its realistic representation of the experience of migration, race, discrimination, memory, and identity reconstruction, provides students with concrete and tangible examples of Homi K. Bhabha's theoretical concepts, including cultural hybridity, the third space, mimicry, and othering. The novel's narrative structure brings these concepts out of abstraction and makes them understandable in the form of human and social experiences.
The review of Persian and international research showed that the use of this novel in university education can contribute to strengthening critical thinking, enhancing intercultural competence, improving the skills of literary analysis, and deepening students' understanding of identity, migration, and power relations. However, these findings have been obtained mainly in Western cultural and educational contexts and cannot be generalized to the Iranian higher education system without localization. The present study, by focusing on the Iranian higher education context, has assessed the pedagogical capacities of the novel based on the criteria of university educational resources.
The findings indicate that Americanah, in addition to its literary value, possesses considerable pedagogical capacity for teaching the concepts of cultural and postcolonial studies and can be used as a supplementary resource alongside traditional theoretical texts in courses on cultural studies, comparative literature, postcolonial studies, and language teaching. However, success in the educational use of this novel requires the design of appropriate curricula, the development of teaching guides, the familiarity of instructors with contemporary postcolonial theories, and attention to the cultural differences between Iranian society and the historical context of the novel. Moreover, the actual effectiveness of this novel in Iranian university classrooms requires field studies and the measurement of students' and instructors' reactions, which were not conducted in the present study and are recommended for future research. Overall, the findings suggest that Americanah exemplifies the connection between literature and education and can serve as a model for the purposeful use of literary works in teaching the complex concepts of the humanities. The use of such works, in addition to enhancing the quality of learning, provides the basis for developing a critical perspective, intercultural dialogue, and a deeper understanding of identity transformations in the contemporary world.

کلیدواژه‌ها English

Narrative and theory
Americanah
Third Space
intercultural education
university curriculum

مقالات آماده انتشار، اصلاح شده برای چاپ
انتشار آنلاین از 02 آبان 1405